FINAL RESULTS OF VOTING #1
(Minimum votes lowered to 3)

Deathmatch
DM Lost Village: 7.5, 7.0, 8.0 = 7.5 - accepted
DM Bunker Hill: 7.0, 6.0, 6.0 = 6.66 - rejected

Capture the flag
CTF Mineshaft: 7.5, 9.0, 8.0, 7.0, 7.5, 8.5, 9.0 = 8.07 - accepted
CTF Maya2: 6.0, 8.5, 7.5, 7.0, 7.5, 7.5, 9.0, 8.0, 8.0 = 7.66 - accepted
CTF Sceptic: 7.0, 6.5, 6.5, 9.5 = 7.25 - rejected
CTF Pitfall: 9.0, 8.0, 7.0, 9.0, 7.0, 9.0 = 8.17 - accepted
CTF Canyons: 7.5, 9.0, 8.0, 9.5 = 8.5 - accepted
CTF Nuubia: 9.0, 2.5, 9.0, 7.5, 8.5, 5.0, 7.5, 8.0 = 7,13 - rejected
CTF Swamp: 8.0, 10.0, 8.0, 8.5, 7.5, 6.5, 8.0, 9.0 = 8,19 - accepted
CTF Bridge: 10.0, 5.0, 7.0, 8.0, 7.5, 8.5, 8.5, 8.0 = 7,81 - accepted

Infiltration
INF Industrial: 8.5, 8.0, 5.0, 8.5, 9.0, 8.5 = 7,92 - accepted
INF DeltaB: 8.0, 5.5, 7.0, 8.5, 8.0 = 7,4 - rejected

Various
VAR Dodgeball, Basketball, Soccer: 5.0*
KZ Sky: 7.0, 7.0** - rejected

* will have another chance (see my reply)
** not enough votes

The maps will be entered into the TOP MAPS thread soon.


_______
How was the candidate list created?
By the suggestions in the ~~~TOP MAPS~~~ thread ;)

Now that we have some suggestions, we shall vote, which of the suggested maps shall really be listed in the TOP MAPS thread. This voting will be done about once a month, depending on the number of suggestions. This time there are quite few, but see this as a "test run", to find out if the voting works as planned.

Once a map has been candidate in this thread, it cannot be a candidate again, either it succeeds here or it is not "TOP" enough ;)

Once a map can achieve an average score of about 8, it will be entered into the TOP MAPS list. The map must have at least been voted 5 times, to obtain a valid score (to avoid maps being entered into the list only because of one vote).

Before there are any misunderstandings...

What makes a top map?
Simply explained: good gameplay that is generally liked and also at least adequate looks (xcept for maps of the VAR category). Keep that in mind, dont vote as generously as you may vote in a map's presentation thread, try to at least test a map before giving any points for it. Be strict, since we really only want to have the best maps in the TOP MAPS thread.

So far for the advice, here are
teh rules:

- You can give each map 0-10 points in 0.5 steps (votings like -3 or 12 wont be accepted, also not serious votings [e.g. someone giving each map 10 or 0 points) will not be counted.

- You cannot vote on your own maps.

- You dont have to vote each map, so please only vote those maps you have really tried.

- Vote like this:
CTF
#1 6.5
#2 9.0
...

INF
#1 8.5
etc.


Here are the candidates:

~~~ TOP MAPS VOTING #1 ~~~

DM Deathmatch
#1 DM Lost Village
http://www.laughingllamas.com/members/*sprocket*/uploads/Lost%20Village.zip
Screen: http://www.laughingllamas.com/members/*sprocket*/uploads/Overview7.jpg

#2 DM Bunker Hill
http://www.laughingllamas.com/members/*sprocket*/uploads/Bunker%20Hill.zip
Screen: http://www.laughingllamas.com/members/*sprocket*/uploads/Overview4.jpg



CTF Capture The Flag
#1 ctf_Mineshaft
http://archive.forums.soldat.pl/topic.php?topic_id=19511

#2 ctf_Maya2
http://archive.forums.soldat.pl/topic.php?topic_id=19870

#3 ctf_Sceptic
http://archive.forums.soldat.pl/topic.php?topic_id=17292

#4 ctf_Pitfall
http://archive.forums.soldat.pl/topic.php?topic_id=19316

#5 ctf_Canyons
http://archive.forums.soldat.pl/topic.php?topic_id=19190

#6 ctf_Nuubia
http://soldat.4players.de/webv3/content/sd_maps.php?action=details&id=108

#7 ctf_Swamp
http://www.denacke.net/Dibo/stuff/ctf_Swamp.PMS

#8 ctf_Bridge
http://www.denacke.net/Dibo/stuff/ctf_Bridge.PMS



INF Infiltration
#1 inf_Industrial
http://archive.forums.soldat.pl/topic.php?topic_id=19557&whichpage=1&SearchTerms=industrial[

#2 inf_DeltaB
http://archive.forums.soldat.pl/topic.php?topic_id=18728&SearchTerms=deltab



RCE KZ VAR Race, Climbing, Other Gamemodes
Soccer, Basketball and Dodgeball :D
#1 Dodgeball, Basketball, Soccer
http://archive.forums.soldat.pl/topic.php?topic_id=19462
http://archive.forums.soldat.pl/topic.php?topic_id=19144
http://archive.forums.soldat.pl/topic.php?topic_id=18906

#2 kz_sky



And now go and vote on your top maps ;)
Voting time extended one week. (Jan-16)


(rejected as candidate: Bigfalls, cause it is already a standard map)

Since I was stupid/tired/whatever enough to kill the old thread accidentally, I will now repost the votings that have been posted until now (n00bface had them archived luckily, thanks for helping me out man)

Avarax:

ctf:
#1: 7.5
#2: 6
#6: 9
#7: 8
#8: 10

inf:
#1: 8.5

---------------------
skate4razors:

DeathMatch:
#2: 7/10

Capture The Flag:
#1: 9/10
#2: 8.5/10
#4: 9/10
#7: 10/10 Yeah, sorry, but this map is the best. And yes, I have actually played this map a lot. I love it.

Infiltration:
#2: 8/10

---------------------

vijchtidoodah:

CTF
#2 ctf_Maya2: 7.5
#4 ctf_Pitfall: 8.0
#5 ctf_Canyons: 7.5
#6 ctf_Nuubia: 2.5
#7 ctf_Swamp: 8.0
#8 ctf_Bridge: 5.0

INF
#1 inf_Industrial: 5.0
#2 inf_DeltaB: 5.5

---------------------

grand_diablo:

Here go my own votings.

DM Deathmatch
#1 7.0


CTF Capture The Flag
#1 ctf_Mineshaft: 8.0
#3 ctf_Sceptic: 7.0
#4 ctf_Pitfall: 7.0
#5 ctf_Canyons: 9.0
#6 ctf_Nuubia: 9.0
#7 ctf_Swamp: 8.5
#8 ctf_Bridge: 7.0


RCE KZ VAR Race, Climbing, Other Gamemodes

#1 Dodgeball, Basketball, Soccer: 5.0
#2 kz_sky: 7.0
---------------------

All those who haven't voted yet, can go on as usual ;)

ctf_Nuubia 7.5
ctf_Bridge 8.0
kz_sky 7.0
ctf_Skeptic 6.5
dm_Lost Village 8.0
ctf_Maya2 7.0
Swamp. 7.5

Dodgeball, etc. 6.0
inf_Industrial 8.0
inf_DeltaB 7.0
EDIT: took all the numbers out, I jubled them all up :p

i have to try more maps, but those are the basics for me...

CTF
#1: 7
#2: 7.5
#4: 9
#6: 8.5
#7: 6.5
#8: 7.5

CTF
#1: 7.5
#2: 7.5
#3: 6.5
#4: 7
#5: 8
#6: 5

some are good..

ctf #2: 9.0
ctf #8: 8.5

VAR #1: 7.0

inf #1: 8.5

DM #2: 6.0

^ those r 1s ive played, ill vote rest as 5.0

INF
#1: 9.0

Soccer is not made by me, can I vote it?

quote:Originally posted by yukwunhangINF
#1: 9.0

Soccer is not made by me, can I vote it?


yes

CTF
#1 8.5
#2 8.0
#3 9.5
#4 9.0
#5 9.5
#6 7.5
#7 8.0
#8 8.5

INF
#2 8.5

But you count dodgeball, basketball and soccer as one map.I made dodgeball and basketball, but not soccer.

DM
#1 7.0
#2 6.0

CTF
#1 9.0
#2 8.0
#7 8.0
#7 9.0
#8 8.0

INF
#1 8.5
#1 8.0

quote:Originally posted by yukwunhangBut you count dodgeball, basketball and soccer as one map.I made dodgeball and basketball, but not soccer.


the suggestion looked as if they were ment to be posted as one candidate. Well, ill add them as single candidates to vote #2 ;)

quote:Originally posted by MOFO NOFOctf #2: 9.0
ctf #8: 8.5

VAR #1: 7.0

inf #1: 8.5

DM #2: 6.0

^ those r 1s ive played, ill vote rest as 5.0

:|

what>?, lol...

He didn't count your vote.

I actually counted all votes, except "^ those r 1s ive played, ill vote rest as 5.0", cause you cannot ruin the average rating of a map you havent played, since you dont even need to vote on each map :>

To save you a little time,and prevent you from having to click on every link, here is a .zip of the 15 maps: http://www.soldatworld.com/fileupload/index.php?act=view&file=QmVzdCAxNS56aXA=