quote:Originally posted by Stalky
Ok, I think everyone has had their say and its time to close this baby.That's actually a complete contradiction to what you said earlier:quote:Originally posted by Stalky
Actually, it wasn't. I didn't fancy trying to take votes from all the normal members, too much indecisiveness and arguing. I just left the voting to the moderators.As much as I hate to disagree with you, Stalky, to be honest, I think the voting on the forum logo was pretty much non-existent. This may be a democracy, but the only "democracy" that was going on was in the Moderators forum. Although it's something small, it still changes the look of this forum, and the winner should have been decided by the result of the votes by the members of this forum, not just the moderators. That's just plain unfair.
Judging from the responses in this thread, most of the people don't like the logo. I personally think it doesn't represent Soldat at all and makes the forum look like a joke. I call for a re-vote, and this time it should be done properly. You complained that there was 'too much indecisiveness and arguing', well it was your job to moderate that topic and set out clear guidelines for the voters. One word posts by the voters which should only include the name of the logos creator and perhaps the image of the logo included; there should be no trouble moderating this. I don't care if the same logo wins as long as it does in a fair poll.
Ok, I think everyone has had their say and its time to close this baby.That's actually a complete contradiction to what you said earlier:quote:Originally posted by Stalky
Actually, it wasn't. I didn't fancy trying to take votes from all the normal members, too much indecisiveness and arguing. I just left the voting to the moderators.As much as I hate to disagree with you, Stalky, to be honest, I think the voting on the forum logo was pretty much non-existent. This may be a democracy, but the only "democracy" that was going on was in the Moderators forum. Although it's something small, it still changes the look of this forum, and the winner should have been decided by the result of the votes by the members of this forum, not just the moderators. That's just plain unfair.
Judging from the responses in this thread, most of the people don't like the logo. I personally think it doesn't represent Soldat at all and makes the forum look like a joke. I call for a re-vote, and this time it should be done properly. You complained that there was 'too much indecisiveness and arguing', well it was your job to moderate that topic and set out clear guidelines for the voters. One word posts by the voters which should only include the name of the logos creator and perhaps the image of the logo included; there should be no trouble moderating this. I don't care if the same logo wins as long as it does in a fair poll.